NEWS, SPORTS, COMMENTARY, POLITICS for Gloucester City and the Surrounding Areas of South Jersey and Philadelphia

Terrence Lee Scott, Sr. age 57, of Woodbury
Update on Tabernacle Murders

Amid Crises, Obama Pushes Out Hagel as Defense Secretary

HagelHagel (Photo credit: Wikipedia)


Josh Siegel / November 24, 2014

Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel resigned today after less than two years in the post amid the struggles of President Obama’s national security team to respond to a slew of global crises.

Hagel, the only Republican in Obama’s Cabinet, is widely believed to have been pushed out by the president as he seeks a different approach to enduring challenges such as the Islamic State terrorist group and the deadly Ebola virus.

Hagel, 68, a low-key former U.S. senator from Nebraska and combat veteran of the Vietnam War, had been skeptical about the Iraq War. He endured a brutal confirmation process in the Senate, where critics questioned his familiarity with the issues, to get the top Pentagon job.

>>> Commentary: Chuck Hagel Learned to Love the Bomb. Will His Successor?

Hagel came in with the assignment from Obama to manage the withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan and to lead a significant paring of the military budget.

In an awkward announcement of his departure shortly after 11 a.m. from the White House’s State Dining Room, Obama, with Hagel and a sullen-looking Vice President Joe Biden flanking him, thanked Hagel for providing a “steady hand” and “bolstering America’s leadership in the world.”

Obama, listing what he called accomplishments on Hagel’s watch, said it was the “appropriate time” for Hagel to go.

After Hagel’s own gracious but general remarks, the president initiated a hug with the man he called a close friend and adviser.

Hagel becomes the third defense secretary to resign under Obama, following Robert Gates and Leon Panetta.

He called his tenure the “greatest privilege” of his life and vowed to stay on and work “just as hard every moment” until the Senate confirms his successor.

Hagel ended his remarks by offering a hearty “Happy Thanksgiving” to “team members” seated in the audience, including the also-departing Attorney General Eric Holder, National Security Adviser Susan Rice and Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Such politeness and deference may have been Hagel’s undoing, some argue.

Hagel and Obama shared mutual opposition to the Iraq War from their former perches on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. Obama noted his gratitude that his Republican colleague had accompanied him on a trip to Afghanistan after he won the Democratic presidential nomination in 2008.

“This news is unsurprising,” said Steve Bucci, a foreign and national security policy expert at The Heritage Foundation who is a former top Pentagon official and Army Special Forces officer. Bucci, calling the forced resignation a “diversion,” told The Daily Signal:


 Hagel never really had the skills for the position; he was put in place solely to provide cover for the budget slashing at the Department of Defense. By kicking him to the side of the road, Obama loses nothing, save a timid voice who was just starting to point out that the president’s Iraq/Syria policy was not working. The foreign and defense policy failure is the president’s, and firing Hagel is nothing more than a diversion, the equivalent of saying, ‘Ignore that man behind the curtain.’


Hagel had struggled to articulate the administration’s strategy to counter the rise of the Islamic State, the brutal terrorist group also known as ISIS or ISIL, and fought with the White House’s National Security Council over how to best deal with Syria’s three-year civil war.

>>> ISIS Video Shows British Hostage ‘Reporting’ Fall of Syrian Town

Hagel recently sent a memo to Rice arguing for more clarity on how to confront Syrian President Bashar Assad.

The White House is carrying out out a limited military role in Syria focused on combating ISIS —  and not on removing the dictator Assad from office.

Dempsey, as chairman of the Joint Chiefs, seemingly grabbed the spotlight from Hagel in recent months by frequently making public comments about the possible need to send U.S. ground troops to fight ISIS.

Obama has resisted that possibility.

Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., a friend and critic of Hagel’s, hinted at heavy-handedness in Obama’s approach to foreign affairs and defense policy as a reason for the broken partnership. In a statement, McCain said:


I know that Chuck was frustrated with aspects of the administration’s national security policy and decision-making process. His predecessors have spoken about the excessive micro-management they faced from the White House and how that made it more difficult to do their jobs successfully. Chuck’s situation was no different.


Michèle A. Flournoy, a former under secretary of defense, and Ashton B. Carter, a former deputy secretary of defense, were quickly mentioned as potential Hagel successors.

Bucci called both candidates “very capable.”

But any defense secretary might not hold much weight in carrying out Obama’s policies, he argued.

“He needs to pick someone who is competent and has the spine to stand up to the president,” Bucci said. “But whoever he puts in there won’t have an ability to make a lot of difference.”

posted with permission